Star Casino judge: Don’t label probing directors as ‘difficult

Thursday, 19 November 2026

    Current

    In a wide-ranging fireside chat at a recent AICD event in Canberra, Federal Court judge, the Hon Justice Michael Lee said that good governance is about asking the questions that matter. 


    Directors cannot be passive recipients of information and must bring an “inquiring mind” to the boardroom, challenge management where something does not ring true and ensure there is a visible record of the questions they have asked, Justice Lee told the audience at the annual lunch for AICD members in the ACT. Directors who probe, request further analysis or seek clarification should not be dismissed as difficult, he said.


    Speaking with AICD General Manager, Education and Policy Leadership Louise Petschler, he reflected on the lessons arising from the Star Entertainment Group case that he presided over and the broader expectations placed on directors. His central message is simple: good governance begins with understanding the business, recognising its particular risks and being prepared to ask the questions that matter.

    Watch the full conversation to hear Justice Lee’s candid perspective on stewardship, board reporting, AI and why active curiosity remains one of a director’s most important safeguards.

    The conversation also explored a familiar boardroom challenge: information overload. Justice Lee is sharply critical of vast electronic document dumps masquerading as board packs, warning that important risks cannot be allowed to disappear on page 734. Boards, and particularly chairs, must take control of the information they receive and insist on reporting that is concise, comprehensible and focused on the organisation’s most material risks. 

    Artificial intelligence offers one possible way forward. Justice Lee sees AI as a valuable tool for synthesising information and freeing directors from mechanical tasks, provided its use is transparent and supported by safeguards for confidentiality and privilege. But he is equally clear that AI cannot assume a director’s responsibilities. Judgement remains a “deeply human” exercise, shaped by experience, perspective and collective deliberation. 

    From the future of board minutes to the warning signs that should prompt deeper inquiry, the discussion offers practical reflections for directors navigating rising complexity.  

    Latest news

    This is of of your complimentary pieces of content

    This is exclusive content.

    You have reached your limit for guest contents. The content you are trying to access is exclusive for AICD members. Please become a member for unlimited access.